Arc Welding Hazard Analysis: Essential Tips for Workplace Safety and Solutions

Arc welding hazard analysis identifies dangers associated with welding. It highlights risks like toxic fumes, burns, explosions, electric shock, and heat stress. These hazards can lead to serious injuries or even death. Implementing effective safety measures significantly improves protection during welding activities.

Proper personal protective equipment (PPE) is essential. Workers should wear welding helmets with appropriate filters, flame-resistant clothing, and gloves. Adequate ventilation is also vital to minimize fumes and gases produced during welding. This further enhances safety and reduces respiratory hazards.

Regular training is necessary to educate workers on safe arc welding practices. Safety programs should cover equipment handling, hazard recognition, and emergency response protocols. Implementing engineering controls, like fume extraction systems, can significantly mitigate risks.

By conducting thorough hazard analyses, workplaces can cultivate a safer environment. This allows workers to focus on their tasks without fear of injury.

Next, we will discuss best practices for integrating hazard analysis into a comprehensive safety program, ensuring ongoing compliance and enhancing worker safety even further.

What Are the Primary Hazards of Arc Welding That Workers Should Know?

The primary hazards of arc welding that workers should know include exposure to harmful fumes and gases, electrical shock, heat burns, and ultraviolet radiation.

  1. Harmful fumes and gases
  2. Electrical shock
  3. Heat burns
  4. Ultraviolet radiation
  5. Fire hazards
  6. Eye injuries
  7. Noise exposure

Understanding these hazards is vital for ensuring safety in the welding environment.

  1. Harmful Fumes and Gases: Harmful fumes and gases are produced during the arc welding process. These can include metal oxides and volatile organic compounds that pose serious health risks. The American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) notes that prolonged exposure can lead to respiratory problems and long-term health issues. For example, manganese exposure can cause neurological damage, as highlighted in a study by the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) in 2019.

  2. Electrical Shock: Electrical shock occurs when a worker comes into direct contact with an electric current. The risk is higher in wet environments or if the welder’s equipment is defective. According to the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), electrical hazards are a leading cause of workplace injuries in welding. Workers must use insulated tools and wear appropriate personal protective equipment (PPE).

  3. Heat Burns: Heat burns can result from contact with hot equipment or molten metal. The high temperatures involved in arc welding can lead to severe burns if proper safety measures are not taken. A 2021 report from the American Welding Society emphasizes the necessity of wearing heat-resistant gloves and protective clothing to minimize burn risks.

  4. Ultraviolet Radiation: Ultraviolet radiation is emitted during the welding arc and can cause serious eye injuries and skin burns. The International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) classifies UV radiation as a potential carcinogen. Welders should wear protective helmets with appropriate filters and clothing to guard against these risks.

  5. Fire Hazards: Fire hazards exist due to the flammable materials used in welding. Sparks can ignite combustible substances nearby, leading to fires. OSHA stresses that a fire watch should be in place during welding operations to prevent accidents.

  6. Eye Injuries: Eye injuries commonly result from exposure to intense light and flying sparks during welding. The National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) recommends using face shields and safety goggles to protect the eyes.

  7. Noise Exposure: Noise exposure is another concern, especially in environments where multiple welding activities occur. Prolonged exposure to high noise levels can lead to hearing loss. According to the CDC, proper hearing protection should be used in noisy work environments to mitigate this risk.

Recognizing these hazards and implementing appropriate safety measures can significantly reduce the risk of accidents and injuries associated with arc welding.

How Can Electrical Hazards Pose Risks in Arc Welding?

Electrical hazards in arc welding pose significant risks due to high voltage, electric shock potential, and equipment malfunctions. These factors can lead to severe injuries or fatalities for workers.

High voltage: Arc welding typically operates at voltages ranging from 20 to 80 volts. If a worker comes into contact with live electrical components, they risk receiving an electric shock. The severity of the shock depends on the voltage level, current intensity, and path through the body. According to the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), shocks as low as 50 volts can be hazardous.

Electric shock potential: Electric shocks can cause a range of injuries, including burns, muscle contractions, and even heart failure. The National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) reports that electrical hazards are a leading cause of workplace deaths. Safety measures, such as proper insulation and maintaining dry work areas, are essential to minimize shock risks.

Equipment malfunctions: Faulty or improperly maintained welding equipment can create electrical hazards. For instance, damaged cables or defective machines can expose workers to live wires. Regular equipment inspections and maintenance are crucial for safe operations. The American Welding Society (AWS) recommends following established maintenance protocols to ensure equipment is in good working condition.

Inadequate personal protective equipment (PPE): Failure to use appropriate PPE increases the risk of electrical hazards. Workers should wear insulated gloves, dielectric boots, and other protective gear to shield against shocks. According to the American National Standards Institute (ANSI), selecting the correct PPE reduces injury risk.

In conclusion, understanding and addressing electrical hazards in arc welding is vital for worker safety. Continuous training and adherence to safety standards can significantly reduce the risks associated with these hazards.

What Types of Fumes and Gases Are Generated During Arc Welding?

Arc welding generates various fumes and gases that can pose health risks to workers. The most common fumes and gases produced during arc welding include:

  1. Ozone
  2. Nitrogen Dioxide
  3. Carbon Monoxide
  4. Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs)
  5. Metal Oxides

These fumes and gases can have different effects on health and safety in the workplace. Understanding these emissions is crucial for implementing the right safety measures.

Ozone:

Ozone is generated when ultraviolet radiation from the welding arc reacts with oxygen in the air. It can irritate the respiratory system and cause headaches. According to the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), exposure to ozone above 0.1 parts per million (ppm) can lead to adverse health effects.

Nitrogen Dioxide:

Nitrogen dioxide is produced during the high-temperature combustion of nitrogen and oxygen. This gas can irritate the lungs and lower respiratory tract, causing inflammation. A study by the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) emphasizes that regular monitoring is essential since nitrogen dioxide levels can exceed safety standards in confined spaces.

Carbon Monoxide:

Carbon monoxide forms when there is incomplete combustion of carbon-containing materials. It is a colorless and odorless gas that can lead to poisoning. According to the CDC, even short-term exposure can be dangerous, with symptoms including headaches, dizziness, and confusion.

Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs):

VOCs are emitted from welding rods and coatings used during the welding process. They can affect air quality and contribute to respiratory problems. The EPA identifies many VOCs as harmful, and prolonged exposure can lead to long-term health issues.

Metal Oxides:

Metal oxides, such as manganese and nickel oxides, are produced when metals are heated during welding. These compounds can lead to various health issues, including neurologic disorders and lung damage. Research shows that exposure to diese metal fumes can accumulate in the body and pose serious health risks over time.

In conclusion, awareness of the types of fumes and gases produced during arc welding is vital for maintaining a safe work environment. Implementing adequate ventilation and personal protective equipment can help reduce exposure to these harmful substances.

Why Are Fire and Explosion Risks Critical in Arc Welding Settings?

Arc welding settings pose significant fire and explosion risks due to the nature of the process and the materials involved. These risks are critical because they can lead to severe injuries, property damage, and even fatalities if not managed properly.

According to the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), arc welding involves an electric arc to melt and join metal parts. The intense heat and sparks generated during this process increase the likelihood of igniting flammable materials nearby, making fire safety a paramount concern.

The underlying causes of fire and explosion risks in arc welding include several key factors:

  1. Heat Generation: Arc welding produces extreme heat, often exceeding 3,500 degrees Fahrenheit. This heat can ignite flammable materials.
  2. Sparks and Slag: The welding arc creates sparks and molten metal, known as slag, which can fly from the welding area and ignite combustible substances like wood, paper, or chemicals.
  3. Explosive Atmospheres: Certain materials, when heated or combined with welding fumes, can create explosive conditions.

Technical terms relevant to this discussion include:

  • Arc Welding: A welding process that uses an electric arc to generate heat for melting and joining materials.
  • Flammable Materials: Substances that can catch fire easily, such as gasoline, solvents, or cloth.

The mechanisms that contribute to fire and explosion risks are linked to both thermal and chemical properties of materials involved. When the welding arc strikes the base metal, it generates high temperatures that can cause adjacent flammable materials to reach their ignition points. For example, if a welding operation occurs near a stack of oily rags, the elevated temperatures can spark a fire.

Specific conditions contributing to fire and explosion risks include:

  • Poor Ventilation: Inadequate airflow increases the concentration of welding fumes and flammable gases, raising explosion risks.
  • Improper Storage: Storing flammable materials improperly near welding operations increases the chances of ignition. For example, keeping acetylene cylinders close to the welding area without proper separation can lead to catastrophic explosions if they are damaged by sparks.
  • Neglected Maintenance: Failure to maintain equipment can lead to unexpected failures, causing sparks or failures in electrical components, which can also trigger fires.

In summary, the critical fire and explosion risks in arc welding settings stem from the high heat, sparks, and chemical reactions involved in the process. Proper management of these risks is essential for workplace safety.

How Do Arc Welding Hazards Impact Worker Safety and Health?

Arc welding hazards significantly impact worker safety and health by exposing workers to physical, chemical, and thermal risks. These hazards can lead to injuries, illnesses, and long-term health effects.

Physical risks include electric shock and flame burns. Electric shock can occur if workers come into contact with live wires. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS, 2022), electric shock accounts for nearly 30% of welding-related fatalities. Flame burns can occur from the intense heat produced by the welding process. The National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH, 2021) reported that burn injuries are among the most common in welding operations.

Chemical risks involve exposure to hazardous fumes and gases. Arc welding produces metal fumes that can contain harmful substances such as lead and manganese. Exposure to these substances can lead to respiratory issues and other long-term health problems. The World Health Organization (WHO, 2020) highlighted that excessive exposure to welding fumes could lead to lung diseases and neurological disorders.

Thermal risks include exposure to ultraviolet (UV) radiation. Welding produces intense UV light, which can cause skin burns and eye injuries. Prolonged exposure can lead to a condition known as “welder’s flash,” which is a painful inflammation of the cornea. A study in the Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine (Smith et al., 2019) found that nearly 50% of welders reported experiencing eye-related issues due to high UV exposure.

Inadequate safety practices can amplify these hazards. Poor ventilation in welding areas can increase the concentration of harmful fumes. Workers should use adequate personal protective equipment (PPE), such as helmets with UV protection, gloves, and respiratory gear, to mitigate these risks.

To promote safe working conditions, employers must implement rigorous safety training programs. Workers should receive training on recognizing hazards, the proper use of PPE, and emergency response procedures. Regular safety audits can also help identify and address potential risks.

In summary, arc welding hazards significantly affect worker safety and health through various physical, chemical, and thermal risks. Awareness and adherence to safety practices can prevent injuries and protect workers’ long-term health.

What are the Short-Term and Long-Term Effects of Exposure to Welding Hazards?

Exposure to welding hazards can lead to short-term and long-term health effects. Short-term effects may include immediate physical symptoms, while long-term effects can result in chronic health conditions.

  1. Short-Term Effects:
    – Eye injuries (welding flashes)
    – Skin burns
    – Respiratory irritation
    – Headaches and dizziness
    – Unstable mental functions

  2. Long-Term Effects:
    – Chronic respiratory diseases (e.g., asthma, bronchitis)
    – Neurological damage
    – Skin cancer
    – Hearing loss
    – Increased risk of cardiovascular diseases

Understanding both short-term and long-term effects helps in mitigating these risks effectively.

  1. Short-Term Effects:
    Short-term effects of exposure to welding hazards occur immediately or shortly after the exposure. These effects often manifest as physical discomfort or injury. For instance, eye injuries often occur from bright light or sparks, causing flash burns or retinal damage. The American Academy of Ophthalmology emphasizes wearing protective goggles to prevent such injuries. Skin burns can happen due to contact with hot metal or sparks, leading to pain and potential infection.

Respiratory irritation can occur from fumes and gases released during welding. Short-term exposure may result in cough or throat discomfort, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Additionally, headaches and dizziness may be symptoms of low oxygen levels or poor ventilation in the workspace. The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) recommends ensuring proper ventilation to mitigate these effects. Lastly, unstable mental functions may arise due to fatigue or exposure to toxic substances, affecting concentration and decision-making ability.

  1. Long-Term Effects:
    Long-term effects of welding hazards develop over months or years. They can lead to serious health issues that significantly impact quality of life. Chronic respiratory diseases such as asthma or bronchitis may develop from repeated exposure to welding fumes. The World Health Organization (WHO) reports that these conditions can significantly impede lung function and overall health.

Neurological damage can occur from exposure to heavy metals like lead or manganese commonly found in welding materials. Research by Bankim Kumar et al. (2020) indicates that such exposure can lead to cognitive impairments over time. Furthermore, skin cancer risk increases with chronic exposure to UV radiation from welding arcs, as reported by the Skin Cancer Foundation.

Hearing loss is another long-term effect due to high noise levels during welding operations. According to the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH), cumulative exposure to loud environments can cause irreversible auditory damage. Lastly, increased risk of cardiovascular diseases has been correlated with long-term exposure to certain welding fumes. A study by the American Heart Association noted that welders have a higher prevalence of hypertension and heart disease, emphasizing the need for regular health check-ups and effective workplace safety measures.

What Key Safety Measures Should Be Implemented in Arc Welding Workplaces?

The key safety measures that should be implemented in arc welding workplaces include effective hazard control, personal protective equipment (PPE), proper ventilation, employee training, and regular safety inspections.

  1. Hazard Control
  2. Personal Protective Equipment (PPE)
  3. Proper Ventilation
  4. Employee Training
  5. Regular Safety Inspections

These measures are vital to ensuring a safe working environment for welders and preventing accidents and injuries. Below is a detailed explanation of each safety measure.

  1. Hazard Control:
    Hazard control refers to identifying and minimizing risks associated with arc welding. This includes removing flammable materials, securing gas cylinders, and employing protective barriers. According to the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), proper hazard controls can reduce workplace injuries by up to 50%. For example, ensuring that welding areas are clear of combustible materials can prevent fire risks, a major hazard in welding operations.

  2. Personal Protective Equipment (PPE):
    Personal protective equipment (PPE) is essential in arc welding to protect workers from burns, fumes, and radiations. This includes welding helmets, gloves, and protective clothing. The American National Standards Institute (ANSI) states that welders must wear helmets with appropriate shading to protect against UV and infrared radiation. For instance, using a helmet with a shade number of 10 to 14 can significantly reduce exposure to harmful light.

  3. Proper Ventilation:
    Proper ventilation is crucial in arc welding to manage hazardous fumes and gases produced during the process. Adequate ventilation systems, such as exhaust hoods or fume extractors, should be installed to ensure clean air circulation. The American Welding Society recommends that welding areas be ventilated according to specific calculations based on the type of welding and materials used. For example, local exhaust ventilation can capture fumes at the source, significantly reducing inhalation risks.

  4. Employee Training:
    Employee training is fundamental for promoting safety awareness and ensuring workers understand the risks associated with arc welding. Welders should receive formal training in safe practices, emergency response, and equipment handling. A study by the Institute for Occupational Safety and Health indicates that workplaces with comprehensive training programs can see a 40% reduction in accidents. Effective training ensures that workers are well-prepared to respond to emergencies and reduce unsafe behaviors.

  5. Regular Safety Inspections:
    Regular safety inspections involve frequent assessments of welding equipment, work areas, and overall safety practices. Inspections should check for malfunctioning equipment, adequate PPE usage, and compliance with safety protocols. The National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) emphasizes that regular inspections can uncover potential hazards before they lead to incidents. For instance, identifying wear and tear on welding machinery can prevent accidents and improve overall safety in the workplace.

By implementing these measures, arc welding workplaces can protect employees from injuries and contribute to a safer work environment.

Which Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) is Crucial for Welders?

Welders need specific Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) to ensure their safety while working. Crucial PPE for welders includes protective clothing, helmets, gloves, and respiratory protection.

  1. Protective Clothing
  2. Welding Helmet
  3. Gloves
  4. Respiratory Protection
  5. Safety Boots
  6. Face Shields

Understanding these PPE types is essential for maintaining safety standards in welding environments. Each type of PPE plays a unique role in protecting welders from various hazards related to their work.

  1. Protective Clothing: Protective clothing acts as a barrier against sparks, heat, and harmful UV radiation produced during welding. Welders should wear flame-resistant jackets or coveralls made from materials like cotton or leather. These garments resist burns and reduce the risk of skin injuries. According to the American National Standards Institute (ANSI), welding clothing must meet specific flame-resistance standards to ensure maximum safety.

  2. Welding Helmet: A welding helmet protects the eyes and face from intense light and radiation produced by the welding arc. It usually features a dark lens to prevent eye damage. Auto-darkening helmets provide the added advantage of automatically adjusting the lens shade based on the welding intensity. Studies from the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) emphasize the importance of proper eye protection to prevent conditions like welder’s flash.

  3. Gloves: Welding gloves protect the hands from heat and sparks. They should be made of heat-resistant materials, such as leather, to prevent burns and provide a good grip. Gloves should also allow for dexterity while manipulating tools and materials. The American Welding Society highlights the importance of selecting gloves that fit well to improve both comfort and protection.

  4. Respiratory Protection: Respiratory protection is crucial for welders working in environments with harmful gases and fumes. Depending on the situation, welders may use half-mask respirators or powered air-purifying respirators. According to a study from the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), effective respiratory protection can significantly lower the risk of respiratory diseases in workers exposed to welding fumes.

  5. Safety Boots: Safety boots should meet protective toe standards and offer slip resistance, ensuring that welders can work safely in various conditions. Steel-toed boots protect feet from heavy equipment or falling objects, while slip-resistant soles reduce the risk of slipping. The National Safety Council indicates that foot injuries are common in welding, and proper footwear can help minimize these occurrences.

  6. Face Shields: Face shields provide additional protection against flying debris and splashes from molten metal. They should be worn in conjunction with a welding helmet for full-face protection. Research from the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) indicates that face shields significantly reduce the risk of facial injuries from welding activities.

In conclusion, using the appropriate Personal Protective Equipment is critical for welders to mitigate the risks associated with their work. Each component of PPE plays a vital role in safeguarding against burns, injuries, and long-term health issues.

How Can Ventilation Systems Reduce the Risks Associated with Arc Welding?

Ventilation systems effectively reduce the risks associated with arc welding by improving air quality, minimizing exposure to harmful fumes, and supporting proper thermal regulation.

Improving air quality: Ventilation systems help replace contaminated air with fresh air. This process reduces the concentration of hazardous pollutants, such as metal fumes and gases released during welding. A study by the American Industrial Hygiene Association (AIHA) in 2019 revealed that effective ventilation can lower total airborne particulate levels by up to 80%.

Minimizing exposure to harmful fumes: Arc welding generates fumes containing toxic substances such as manganese, lead, and nickel. Proper ventilation captures and removes these fumes from the workspace. The National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) recommends local exhaust ventilation systems to capture fumes at the source. This method has been shown to decrease fume exposure levels significantly.

Supporting proper thermal regulation: Ventilation systems help to control temperature in the welding area. High temperatures can cause discomfort and decrease productivity. Effective ventilation allows workers to maintain a comfortable working environment. The American Welding Society (AWS) states that maintaining an optimal temperature can increase worker efficiency by approximately 15%.

Enhancing worker comfort and safety: Good ventilation reduces the risk of heat stress and fatigue, which can occur during lengthy welding tasks. By ensuring airflow, workers can breathe easier and perform their tasks with greater focus. A well-ventilated workspace contributes to overall worker safety and satisfaction.

In conclusion, the effective use of ventilation systems in arc welding environments is crucial for protecting workers’ health and improving operational efficiency.

What Training and Best Practices Are Necessary to Prevent Arc Welding Hazards?

To prevent arc welding hazards, proper training and adherence to best practices are essential. Effective safety measures ensure the well-being of workers and enhance workplace efficiency.

  1. Comprehensive Training Programs
  2. Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) Usage
  3. Proper Ventilation Systems
  4. Regular Equipment Maintenance
  5. Safety Procedures and Protocols
  6. Awareness of Electric Shock Risks
  7. Safe Material Handling Practices
  8. Environmental Safety Measures

Understanding these points is vital for building a robust safety culture in welding environments. Each factor significantly contributes to minimizing risks and ensuring worker safety.

  1. Comprehensive Training Programs: Comprehensive training programs are critical for welding safety. These programs offer hands-on experience and theoretical knowledge about arc welding techniques, equipment operation, and safety protocols. According to a study by the National Safety Council in 2021, effective training can decrease workplace accidents by up to 40%. Companies like Lincoln Electric emphasize that training fosters awareness of hazards and proper emergency responses, enhancing overall safety.

  2. Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) Usage: Personal protective equipment (PPE) usage is essential in arc welding environments. Workers must wear helmets, gloves, aprons, and eye protection specifically designed to shield against sparks, ultraviolet light, and heat. The ANSI Z49.1 standard states that appropriate PPE can significantly reduce injury rates associated with welding. For instance, a case study from the American Welding Society found that companies enforcing strict PPE policies reported a 30% decline in burn injuries.

  3. Proper Ventilation Systems: Proper ventilation systems are crucial in preventing hazardous fumes and gases from accumulating during welding. Adequate ventilation removes potentially harmful airborne contaminants and provides fresh air. The American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists recommends local exhaust ventilation as an effective control measure. Research indicates that without proper ventilation, welders may be exposed to levels of manganese and other metals above recommended limits, leading to health issues over time.

  4. Regular Equipment Maintenance: Regular equipment maintenance prevents malfunction and enhances the safety of welding operations. Regular checks on welding equipment, protective gear, and ventilation systems ensure their proper functionality. A study by OSHA revealed that faulty equipment was a significant contributor to workplace accidents. An example is a factory that enforced a strict maintenance schedule, resulting in zero equipment-related injuries over five years.

  5. Safety Procedures and Protocols: Safety procedures and protocols establish guidelines for safe welding practices. These include proper setup, operation, and emergency actions. According to a report by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, adherence to written safety protocols can significantly decrease incident rates. Organizations like the Fabricators and Manufacturers Association emphasize the need for routine safety audits to ensure compliance.

  6. Awareness of Electric Shock Risks: Awareness of electric shock risks is vital during arc welding. Workers must understand the dangers of electric arc exposure and the importance of using insulated equipment. The NFPA states that approximately 1,000 electrical injuries occur yearly in welding settings. Training programs should emphasize safe practices, such as keeping equipment dry and avoiding wet surfaces to mitigate electrical hazards.

  7. Safe Material Handling Practices: Safe material handling practices ensure proper management of materials used in welding. This includes safely storing, transporting, and disposing of welding materials. A study conducted by the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health found that improper handling can lead to accidents resulting in serious injuries. Companies should implement training programs focused on ergonomics and safe lifting techniques to enhance safety.

  8. Environmental Safety Measures: Environmental safety measures address the broader impact of welding processes on the surroundings. This includes proper disposal of hazardous materials and minimizing exposure to welding fumes. Research from the Environmental Protection Agency demonstrates the importance of reducing spill risks and waste management in welding operations. Implementing sustainable practices not only protects workers but also contributes to environmental conservation.

By integrating these essential training and best practices, workplaces can create a safer environment for welders and reduce the incidence of arc welding hazards.

How Frequently Should Job Hazard Analyses Be Conducted in Welding Operations?

Job Hazard Analyses (JHAs) should be conducted at least annually in welding operations. This frequency helps ensure that safety measures remain effective and relevant. Additionally, JHAs should be updated whenever there are changes in equipment, processes, or personnel. Conducting them after accidents or near misses is also critical. This approach helps identify new hazards or changes in risk levels. Keeping JHAs current promotes a safe work environment, guides training, and complies with safety regulations. Regularly reviewing and updating JHAs contributes to the ongoing improvement of safety practices in welding operations.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment